ROLLOUT 7 · pymodbus-dev/pymodbus
pymodbus-dev__pymodbus-1923
Not solved
467 stotal time
8tool calls
8model calls
6,275tokens generated
85,276prompt tokens read
Test failures/errors recorded in JUnit XML (failures=1, errors=0)
Turn by turn
Token shading: p ≥ 0.9 0.5 – 0.9 0.2 – 0.5 below 0.2. Hover a token for its id and probability.
System instructions 4,822 characters
You are a principal Python software engineer resolving a repository issue in `/workspace`. Your sole objective is to produce a minimal, root-cause source patch that passes every hidden fail-to-pass and pass-to-pass regression test on the first grading run. ## Critical Environment & Grader Rules 1. **Air-Gapped Sandbox & Available CLI Tools**: No network access. Never run `pip`, `uv`, `conda`, or `git fetch`. Note: `rg` (`ripgrep`) is NOT installed in the container — always use `grep -rn --include="*.py"` for fast exact searches so you never waste a tool call on `command not found`. 2. **Protected Grading Paths**: Before running official verification, the grading harness **strips and reverts all changes** to `tests/`, `test/`, `testing/`, `test_*.py`, `*_test.py`, `conftest.py`, `pyproject.toml`, `setup.cfg`, `pytest.ini`, and `tox.ini`. Every part of your fix MUST reside in non-test production source files. 3. **Untracked File Trap (`git add -N .`)**: `submit_patch` stages ALL untracked files inside `/workspace`! Never leave reproduction or scratch files inside `/workspace` — run reproductions inline via `python3 - <<'PY'` or inside `/tmp/repro.py` in a single `run_command`. 4. **Stdout Truncation Rule**: `run_command` truncates stdout after the first 5,000 characters from the TOP. Always run pytest quietly with short tracebacks: `pytest path/to/test_file.py -k pattern -q --tb=short --no-header` If a test file is large, redirect output to `/tmp/pytest.log` and inspect `tail -n 80 /tmp/pytest.log` so failure tracebacks at the bottom are never cut off. 5. **Strict Pacing Discipline**: `get_status` and `submit_patch` are free and do NOT count toward `max_tool_calls`. Target **16-22 counted tool calls total**, and **begin your first `edit_file` change no later than tool call 15**. Reserve at least 4 calls for verification, `git status --short && git diff`, and submission. ## Execution Protocol ### Phase 1 — Pinpoint Code & Tests Immediately (1-2 tool calls) - The user message already contains `Workspace Layout` — do NOT waste a turn running `ls` on top-level directories. - Run a single compound `run_command` with `grep -rn --include="*.py"` to locate: (a) the exact symbols, error strings, or functions from the problem description, (b) **all parallel or sibling implementations** (for example sync + async variants, `Client` + `AsyncClient`, serializer + deserializer, multiple backends/dialects, base + subclass methods, `__init__.py` / `__all__` exports), and (c) the closest existing unit test files under `tests/`. ### Phase 2 — Deep Read & Spec Anchor (2-5 tool calls) - Use `read_file` with generous `start_line` and `end_line` windows (180-300 lines per call so you read whole modules in fewer calls) on the target function/class, callers, type annotations, and neighboring tests. - Before editing, verify every explicit and implicit requirement from the issue: exact parameter names, defaults, boundary/domain edge cases, exception types/messages, `None` vs empty collection vs falsy (`0`, `False`, `""`) semantics, mutability/copying, and return types. ### Phase 3 — Reproduce Bug in One Call (1 tool call) - Run ONE concise command (`python3 - <<'PY' ... PY` or targeted `pytest ... -q --tb=short --no-header`) via `run_command` to observe the exact pre-fix failure. Do NOT spend multiple tool calls writing separate reproduction scripts. ### Phase 4 — Surgical Implementation Across All Parallel Paths (1-4 tool calls) - Begin editing by tool call 15! Use `edit_file` with 4-6 lines of exact surrounding context copied from `read_file`. - Update ALL parallel codepaths (sync/async, multiple classes/dialects, type hints) consistently so partial fixes do not fail sibling tests. - **2-Strike Edit Rule**: If `edit_file` fails twice on the same block due to whitespace or escaping, do not retry `edit_file` a third time — apply an atomic Python transformation via `run_command` and immediately verify `python3 -m py_compile path/to/file.py`. ### Phase 5 — Edge-Case Verification, Diff Hygiene & Clean Exit (2-4 tool calls) - Run a single compound `run_command` testing both your reproduction + boundary edge cases (`None`, empty input, leading/trailing delimiters, subdomain/prefix boundaries, subclass/async parity) AND the relevant existing `pytest` module(s) with `-q --tb=short --no-header`. - Run `git status --short && git diff` via `run_command`. Confirm: - ZERO untracked (`??`) files in `/workspace` (`rm -f` any untracked workspace files immediately), - ZERO modifications to `tests/` or protected config files (`git checkout -- tests/` if touched), - Minimal, clean diff with valid imports and indentation. - Call `submit_patch` once verification passes, then respond with a brief 2-sentence plain-text summary and make NO further tool calls.
Task prompt 11,117 characters
You are evaluating a software engineering task for repository pymodbus-dev/pymodbus.
Problem Statement:
Pymodbus doesn't correctly handle Reassembled TCP segments
### Versions
- Python: Python: 3.11.4
- OS: Ubuntu 20.04
- Pymodbus: pymodbus-3.7.0.dev0 (git commit 81df5b1cde349dddd32ac3c1fd97ec4b475c2512) as well as 3.5.4
- Modbus Hardware (if used): SMA STP 6000TL-20 (version 02.51.02.R)
### Pymodbus Specific
- Client: tcp - async
### Description
When trying to read registers from the SMA STP 6000TL Inverter, the Modbus Response is split over 2 frames where the second frame only contains the last required byte. pymodbus doesn't seem to reassemble the modbus frames and instead tries parsing the first frame as a modbus response which it discards because it doesn't pass the Frame check. It then tries reading the second frame (consisting of only one byte) as a response and throws an exception because it can't decode it.
pymodbus should probably check the length of the tcp packet and only run the frame check once the complete packet has arrived. I've attached the client code, pymodbus logs and a wireshark capture of the modbus traffic.
### Code and Logs
[20240104_tcp_reassembly.pcapng.gz](https://github.com/pymodbus-dev/pymodbus/files/13828939/20240104_tcp_reassembly.pcapng.gz)
```python
import asyncio
import pymodbus
from pymodbus.client import AsyncModbusTcpClient
from pymodbus.constants import Endian
from pymodbus.exceptions import ModbusException
from pymodbus.payload import BinaryPayloadDecoder
from pymodbus.pdu import ExceptionResponse
pymodbus.pymodbus_apply_logging_config("DEBUG")
async def main():
async with AsyncModbusTcpClient(
host="127.0.0.1", port=5502, reconnect_delay=0
) as mbus:
response = await mbus.read_holding_registers(42109, 4, slave=1)
decoder = BinaryPayloadDecoder.fromRegisters(
response.registers, byteorder=Endian.BIG, wordorder=Endian.BIG
)
_serial = decoder.decode_32bit_uint()
_susy_id = decoder.decode_16bit_uint()
unit_id = decoder.decode_16bit_uint()
if __name__ == "__main__":
asyncio.run(main())
```
Logs:
```
2024-01-04 11:16:16,385 DEBUG logging:103 Connecting to 127.0.0.1:5502.
2024-01-04 11:16:16,385 DEBUG logging:103 Connecting comm
2024-01-04 11:16:16,385 DEBUG logging:103 Connected to comm
2024-01-04 11:16:16,385 DEBUG logging:103 callback_connected called
2024-01-04 11:16:16,385 DEBUG logging:103 send: 0x0 0x1 0x0 0x0 0x0 0x6 0x1 0x3 0xa4 0x7d 0x0 0x4
2024-01-04 11:16:16,385 DEBUG logging:103 Adding transaction 1
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 recv: 0x0 0x1 0x0 0x0 0x0 0xb 0x1 0x3 0x8 0x0 0xb5 0x12 0x2f 0x37 0x21 0x0 old_data: addr=None
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 Processing: 0x0 0x1 0x0 0x0 0x0 0xb 0x1 0x3 0x8 0x0 0xb5 0x12 0x2f 0x37 0x21 0x0
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 Frame check failed, ignoring!!
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 Resetting frame - Current Frame in buffer - 0x0 0x1 0x0 0x0 0x0 0xb 0x1 0x3 0x8 0x0 0xb5 0x12 0x2f 0x37 0x21 0x0
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 recv: 0x3 old_data: addr=None
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Processing: 0x3
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Factory Response[ReadHoldingRegistersResponse': 3]
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 ERROR logging:115 General exception: index out of range
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Resetting frame - Current Frame in buffer - 0x3
Fatal error: protocol.data_received() call failed.
protocol: <pymodbus.client.tcp.AsyncModbusTcpClient object at 0x7fa70e325f70>
transport: <_SelectorSocketTransport fd=6 read=polling write=<idle, bufsize=0>>
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "/usr/lib/python3.8/asyncio/selector_events.py", line 862, in _read_ready__data_received
self._protocol.data_received(data)
File "/home/simon/tools/pymodbus/pymodbus/transport/transport.py", line 318, in data_received
self.datagram_received(data, None)
File "/home/simon/tools/pymodbus/pymodbus/transport/transport.py", line 352, in datagram_received
cut = self.callback_data(self.recv_buffer, addr=addr)
File "/home/simon/tools/pymodbus/pymodbus/client/base.py", line 186, in callback_data
self.framer.processIncomingPacket(data, self._handle_response, slave=0)
File "/home/simon/tools/pymodbus/pymodbus/framer/base.py", line 139, in processIncomingPacket
self.frameProcessIncomingPacket(single, callback, slave, **kwargs)
File "/home/simon/tools/pymodbus/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py", line 136, in frameProcessIncomingPacket
self._process(callback, tid, error=True)
File "/home/simon/tools/pymodbus/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py", line 154, in _process
raise ModbusIOException("Unable to decode request")
pymodbus.exceptions.ModbusIOException: Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request
2024-01-04 11:16:16,721 DEBUG logging:103 Connection lost comm due to Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request
2024-01-04 11:16:16,721 DEBUG logging:103 Getting transaction 1
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "bug_reproducer.py", line 27, in <module>
asyncio.run(main())
File "/usr/lib/python3.8/asyncio/runners.py", line 44, in run
return loop.run_until_complete(main)
File "/usr/lib/python3.8/asyncio/base_events.py", line 616, in run_until_complete
return future.result()
File "bug_reproducer.py", line 17, in main
response = await mbus.read_holding_registers(42109, 4, slave=1)
File "/home/simon/tools/pymodbus/pymodbus/client/base.py", line 167, in async_execute
resp = await asyncio.wait_for(
File "/usr/lib/python3.8/asyncio/tasks.py", line 494, in wait_for
return fut.result()
pymodbus.exceptions.ConnectionException: Modbus Error: [Connection] Connection lost during request
```
## Task Budget (Session terminates when any budget is exhausted)
- Time allowance: 7.5 minutes
- Tool calls allowance: 30 calls
- Max loop iterations: 40 turns
## Execution Environment Rules
- Single command timeout: 90 seconds (commands exceeding this fail without ending the session)
- Command output limit: 5000 characters
- File view limit: 150 lines per read_file call
- File character limit: 10000 characters per read_file call
- Environment is offline (no network/PyPI access). All repository and test dependencies are ALREADY pre-installed. Do NOT attempt to run pip install or download packages.
## Instructions:
0. All source code is under `/workspace`. Do NOT search outside `/workspace` (e.g. `/usr/`, `/wheels/`, system site-packages). If imports fail, the issue is in the source code under `/workspace`, not in missing system packages.
1. Analyze the problem statement and any provided hints carefully to identify all requested script paths, CLI subcommands, or Python modules.
2. Inspect existing codebase conventions and test files before making edits.
3. Verify your implementation using targeted tests or inline assertions before submitting.
4. Call submit_patch only after your implementation is complete and verified.
5. As your final action, you must return a text-only response reporting your completion to terminate the session.
## Workspace Layout
The repository is located at `/workspace`. Here is the directory tree (up to 3 levels):
```
./API_changes.rst
./AUTHORS.rst
./CHANGELOG.rst
./CONTRIBUTING.rst
./LICENSE
./MAKE_RELEASE.rst
./MANIFEST.in
./README.rst
./check_ci.sh
./doc
./doc/Makefile
./doc/build_html
./doc/conf.py
./doc/index.rst
./doc/source
./doc/source/REPL.rst
./doc/source/_static
./doc/source/api_changes.rst
./doc/source/authors.rst
./doc/source/changelog.rst
./doc/source/client.rst
./doc/source/examples.rst
./doc/source/internals.rst
./doc/source/library
./doc/source/readme.rst
./doc/source/server.rst
./doc/source/simulator.rst
./examples
./githooks
./githooks/pre-commit
./pymodbus
./pymodbus/__init__.py
./pymodbus/bit_read_message.py
./pymodbus/bit_write_message.py
./pymodbus/client
./pymodbus/client/__init__.py
./pymodbus/client/base.py
./pymodbus/client/mixin.py
./pymodbus/client/serial.py
./pymodbus/client/tcp.py
./pymodbus/client/tls.py
./pymodbus/client/udp.py
./pymodbus/constants.py
./pymodbus/datastore
./pymodbus/datastore/__init__.py
./pymodbus/datastore/context.py
./pymodbus/datastore/remote.py
./pymodbus/datastore/simulator.py
./pymodbus/datastore/store.py
./pymodbus/device.py
./pymodbus/diag_message.py
./pymodbus/events.py
./pymodbus/exceptions.py
./pymodbus/factory.py
./pymodbus/file_message.py
./pymodbus/framer
./pymodbus/framer/__init__.py
./pymodbus/framer/ascii_framer.py
./pymodbus/framer/base.py
./pymodbus/framer/binary_framer.py
./pymodbus/framer/rtu_framer.py
./pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py
./pymodbus/framer/tls_framer.py
./pymodbus/logging.py
./pymodbus/mei_message.py
./pymodbus/other_message.py
./pymodbus/payload.py
./pymodbus/pdu.py
./pymodbus/py.typed
./pymodbus/register_read_message.py
./pymodbus/register_write_message.py
./pymodbus/repl
./pymodbus/repl/README.rst
./pymodbus/repl/__init__.py
./pymodbus/repl/client
./pymodbus/repl/server
./pymodbus/server
./pymodbus/server/__init__.py
./pymodbus/server/async_io.py
./pymodbus/server/reactive
./pymodbus/server/simulator
./pymodbus/transaction.py
./pymodbus/transport
./pymodbus/transport/__init__.py
./pymodbus/transport/transport.py
./pymodbus/transport/transport_serial.py
./pymodbus/utilities.py
./pyproject.toml
./test
./test/__init__.py
./test/conftest.py
./test/sub_client
./test/sub_client/test_client.py
./test/sub_client/test_client_faulty_response.py
./test/sub_client/test_client_sync.py
./test/sub_client/test_repl_client.py
./test/sub_examples
./test/sub_examples/__init__.py
./test/sub_examples/conftest.py
./test/sub_examples/test_client_server_async.py
./test/sub_examples/test_client_server_sync.py
./test/sub_examples/test_examples.py
./test/sub_examples/test_helper.py
./test/sub_messages
./test/sub_messages/test_all_messages.py
./test/sub_messages/test_bit_read_messages.py
./test/sub_messages/test_bit_write_messages.py
./test/sub_messages/test_diag_messages.py
./test/sub_messages/test_mei_messages.py
./test/sub_messages/test_other_messages.py
./test/sub_messages/test_register_read_messages.py
./test/sub_messages/test_register_write_messages.py
./test/sub_server
./test/sub_server/test_server_asyncio.py
./test/sub_server/test_server_context.py
./test/sub_server/test_server_multidrop.py
./test/sub_server/test_simulator.py
./test/sub_transport
./test/sub_transport/__init__.py
./test/sub_transport/conftest.py
./test/sub_transport/test_basic.py
./test/sub_transport/test_comm.py
./test/sub_transport/test_nullmodem.py
./test/sub_transport/test_protocol.py
./test/sub_transport/test_reconnect.py
./test/test_device.py
./test/test_events.py
./test/test_exceptions.py
./test/test_factory.py
./test/test_file_message.py
./test/test_framers.py
./test/test_logging.py
./test/test_payload.py
./test/test_pdu.py
./test/test_remote_datastore.py
./test/test_sparse_datastore.py
./test/test_transaction.py
./test/test_utilities.py
```
Turn 1at 44 s498 tokens out6,231 prompt tokens
The user is reporting an issue where `pymodbus` fails to handle reassembled TCP segments.
Specifically, when a Modbus response is split over multiple TCP frames, the first frame is processed independently and fails the frame check, and then the second (incomplete) frame is processed and also fails, leading to a `ModbusIOException: Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request`.
The traceback provided points to:
1. `pymodbus/transport/transport.py` in `data_received` calling `datagram_received`.
2. `pymodbus/transport/transport.py` in `datagram_received` calling `callback_data`.
3. `pymodbus/client/base.py` in `callback_data` calling `self.framer.processIncomingPacket`.
4. `pymodbus/framer/base.py` in `processIncomingPacket` calling `self.frameProcessIncomingPacket`.
5. `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` in `frameProcessIncomingPacket` calling `self._process`.
6. `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` in `_process` raising `ModbusIOException("Unable to decode request")`.
The core of the issue seems to be in `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py`, where it doesn't seem to be buffering the partial packets correctly to wait for the full Modbus TCP frame (which should have a length specified in its header).
Modbus TCP frames start with a MBAP header:
- Transaction Identifier: 2 bytes
- Protocol Identifier: 2 bytes (0 for Modbus)
- Length: 2 bytes (number of bytes from Unit ID to the end of the frame)
- Unit ID: 1 byte
- PDU: variable length
If the received data is shorter than what is specified in the Length field, it should be buffered until the remaining data arrives.
Let's start by examining the code in `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py`.
TOOL CALL · run_command
{
"command": "grep -rn --include=\"*.py\" \"processIncomingPacket\" pymodbus/framer/ | grep -v \"base.py\""
}Result of run_command 127 characters
{
"status": "error",
"error_type": "CommandError",
"error_message": "",
"details": {
"stdout": "",
"stderr": "",
"exit_code": 1
}
}Generated tokens 498 tokens · stopped: STOP
<|channel>thought
The user is reporting an issue where `pymodbus` fails to handle reassembled TCP segments.
Specifically, when a Modbus response is split over multiple TCP frames, the first frame is processed independently and fails the frame check, and then the second (incomplete) frame is processed and also fails, leading to a `ModbusIOException: Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request`.
The traceback provided points to:
1. `pymodbus/transport/transport.py` in `data_received` calling `datagram_received`.
2. `pymodbus/transport/transport.py` in `datagram_received` calling `callback_data`.
3. `pymodbus/client/base.py` in `callback_data` calling `self.framer.processIncomingPacket`.
4. `pymodbus/framer/base.py` in `processIncomingPacket` calling `self.frameProcessIncomingPacket`.
5. `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` in `frameProcessIncomingPacket` calling `self._process`.
6. `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` in `_process` raising `ModbusIOException("Unable to decode request")`.
The core of the issue seems to be in `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py`, where it doesn't seem to be buffering the partial packets correctly to wait for the full Modbus TCP frame (which should have a length specified in its header).
Modbus TCP frames start with a MBAP header:
- Transaction Identifier: 2 bytes
- Protocol Identifier: 2 bytes (0 for Modbus)
- Length: 2 bytes (number of bytes from Unit ID to the end of the frame)
- Unit ID: 1 byte
- PDU: variable length
If the received data is shorter than what is specified in the Length field, it should be buffered until the remaining data arrives.
Let's start by examining the code in `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py`.<channel|><|tool_call>call:run_command{command:<|"|>grep -rn --include="*.py" "processIncomingPacket" pymodbus/framer/ | grep -v "base.py"<|"|>}<tool_call|><|tool_response>
Turn 2at 51 s98 tokens out6,785 prompt tokens
Wait, `grep -rn` returned nothing? That's unexpected. I might have messed up the grep command or the output is empty. Let me try a simpler grep. Actually, I just saw it in the traceback: `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` has `frameProcessIncomingPacket`.
TOOL CALL · read_file
{
"filepath": "pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py"
}Result of read_file 5,838 characters
{
"status": "ok",
"filepath": "pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py",
"content": "\"\"\"Socket framer.\"\"\"\n# pylint: disable=missing-type-doc\nimport struct\n\nfrom pymodbus.exceptions import (\n InvalidMessageReceivedException,\n ModbusIOException,\n)\nfrom pymodbus.framer.base import SOCKET_FRAME_HEADER, ModbusFramer\nfrom pymodbus.logging import Log\n\n\n# --------------------------------------------------------------------------- #\n# Modbus TCP Message\n# --------------------------------------------------------------------------- #\n\n\nclass ModbusSocketFramer(ModbusFramer):\n \"\"\"Modbus Socket Frame controller.\n\n Before each modbus TCP message is an MBAP header which is used as a\n message frame. It allows us to easily separate messages as follows::\n\n [ MBAP Header ] [ Function Code] [ Data ] \\\n [ tid ][ pid ][ length ][ uid ]\n 2b 2b 2b 1b 1b Nb\n\n while len(message) > 0:\n tid, pid, length`, uid = struct.unpack(\">HHHB\", message)\n request = message[0:7 + length - 1`]\n message = [7 + length - 1:]\n\n * length = uid + function code + data\n * The -1 is to account for the uid byte\n \"\"\"\n\n method = \"socket\"\n\n def __init__(self, decoder, client=None):\n \"\"\"Initialize a new instance of the framer.\n\n :param decoder: The decoder factory implementation to use\n \"\"\"\n super().__init__(decoder, client)\n self._hsize = 0x07\n\n # ----------------------------------------------------------------------- #\n # Private Helper Functions\n # ----------------------------------------------------------------------- #\n def checkFrame(self):\n \"\"\"Check and decode the next frame.\n\n Return true if we were successful.\n \"\"\"\n if self.isFrameReady():\n (\n self._header[\"tid\"],\n self._header[\"pid\"],\n self._header[\"len\"],\n self._header[\"uid\"],\n ) = struct.unpack(\">HHHB\", self._buffer[0 : self._hsize])\n\n # someone sent us an error? ignore it\n if self._header[\"len\"] < 2:\n self.advanceFrame()\n # we have at least a complete message, continue\n elif len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1 >= self._header[\"len\"]:\n return True\n # we don't have enough of a message yet, wait\n return False\n\n def advanceFrame(self):\n \"\"\"Skip over the current framed message.\n\n This allows us to skip over the current message after we have processed\n it or determined that it contains an error. It also has to reset the\n current frame header handle\n \"\"\"\n length = self._hsize + self._header[\"len\"] - 1\n self._buffer = self._buffer[length:]\n self._header = {\"tid\": 0, \"pid\": 0, \"len\": 0, \"uid\": 0}\n\n def isFrameReady(self):\n \"\"\"Check if we should continue decode logic.\n\n This is meant to be used in a while loop in the decoding phase to let\n the decoder factory know that there is still data in the buffer.\n\n :returns: True if ready, False otherwise\n \"\"\"\n return len(self._buffer) > self._hsize\n\n def getFrame(self):\n \"\"\"Return the next frame from the buffered data.\n\n :returns: The next full frame buffer\n \"\"\"\n length = self._hsize + self._header[\"len\"] - 1\n return self._buffer[self._hsize : length]\n\n # ----------------------------------------------------------------------- #\n # Public Member Functions\n # ----------------------------------------------------------------------- #\n def decode_data(self, data):\n \"\"\"Decode data.\"\"\"\n if len(data) > self._hsize:\n tid, pid, length, uid, fcode = struct.unpack(\n SOCKET_FRAME_HEADER, data[0 : self._hsize + 1]\n )\n return {\n \"tid\": tid,\n \"pid\": pid,\n \"length\": length,\n \"slave\": uid,\n \"fcode\": fcode,\n }\n return {}\n\n def frameProcessIncomingPacket(self, single, callback, slave, tid=None, **kwargs):\n \"\"\"Process new packet pattern.\n\n This takes in a new request packet, adds it to the current\n packet stream, and performs framing on it. That is, checks\n for complete messages, and once found, will process all that\n exist. This handles the case when we read N + 1 or 1 // N\n messages at a time instead of 1.\n\n The processed and decoded messages are pushed to the callback\n function to process and send.\n \"\"\"\n while True:\n if not self.isFrameReady():\n if len(self._buffer):\n # Possible error ???\n if self._header[\"len\"] < 2:\n self._process(callback, tid, error=True)\n break\n if not self.checkFrame():\n Log.debug(\"Frame check failed, ignoring!!\")\n self.resetFrame()\n continue\n if not self._validate_slave_id(slave, single):\n header_txt = self._header[\"uid\"]\n Log.debug(\"Not a valid slave id - {}, ignoring!!\", header_txt)\n self.resetFrame()\n continue\n self._process(callback, tid)\n\n def _process(self, callback, tid, error=False):\n \"\"\"Process incoming packets irrespective error condition.\"\"\"",
"start_line": 1,
"end_line": 150,
"total_lines": 182,
"is_truncated": true
}Generated tokens 98 tokens · stopped: STOP
Wait, `grep -rn` returned nothing? That's unexpected. I might have messed up the grep command or the output is empty. Let me try a simpler grep.
Actually, I just saw it in the traceback: `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` has `frameProcessIncomingPacket`.
<channel|><|tool_call>call:read_file{filepath:<|"|>pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py<|"|>}<tool_call|><|tool_response>
Turn 3at 57 s70 tokens out8,417 prompt tokens
I need to see the rest of `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` to understand `_process` and `resetFrame`.
TOOL CALL · read_file
{
"filepath": "pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py",
"start_line": 151
}Result of read_file 1,215 characters
{
"status": "ok",
"filepath": "pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py",
"content": " data = self._buffer if error else self.getFrame()\n if (result := self.decoder.decode(data)) is None:\n self.resetFrame()\n raise ModbusIOException(\"Unable to decode request\")\n if error and result.function_code < 0x80:\n raise InvalidMessageReceivedException(result)\n self.populateResult(result)\n self.advanceFrame()\n if tid and tid != result.transaction_id:\n self.resetFrame()\n else:\n callback(result) # defer or push to a thread?\n\n def buildPacket(self, message):\n \"\"\"Create a ready to send modbus packet.\n\n :param message: The populated request/response to send\n \"\"\"\n data = message.encode()\n packet = struct.pack(\n SOCKET_FRAME_HEADER,\n message.transaction_id,\n message.protocol_id,\n len(data) + 2,\n message.slave_id,\n message.function_code,\n )\n packet += data\n return packet\n\n\n# __END__",
"start_line": 151,
"end_line": 182,
"total_lines": 182,
"is_truncated": false
}Generated tokens 70 tokens · stopped: STOP
I need to see the rest of `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` to understand `_process` and `resetFrame`.
<channel|><|tool_call>call:read_file{filepath:<|"|>pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py<|"|>,start_line:151}<tool_call|><|tool_response>
Turn 4at 109 s820 tokens out8,838 prompt tokens
The logic in `frameProcessIncomingPacket` is:
```python
def frameProcessIncomingPacket(self, single, callback, slave, tid=None, **kwargs):
# ...
while True:
if not self.isFrameReady():
if len(self._buffer):
# Possible error ???
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self._process(callback, tid, error=True)
break
if not self.checkFrame():
Log.debug("Frame check failed, ignoring!!")
self.resetFrame()
continue
# ...
self._process(callback, tid)
```
And `isFrameReady`:
```python
def isFrameReady(self):
return len(self._buffer) > self._hsize
```
And `checkFrame`:
```python
def checkFrame(self):
if self.isFrameReady():
(
self._header["tid"],
self._header["pid"],
self._header["len"],
self._header["uid"],
) = struct.unpack(">HHHB", self._buffer[0 : self._hsize])
# someone sent us an error? ignore it
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self.advanceFrame()
# we have at least a complete message, continue
elif len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1 >= self._header["len"]:
return True
# we don't have enough of a message yet, wait
return False
```
Wait, there's a bug here. If `isFrameReady` is True (buffer size > 7), but `checkFrame` is False (meaning we don't have enough data yet for the full frame), then `frameProcessIncomingPacket` does this:
```python
if not self.checkFrame():
Log.debug("Frame check failed, ignoring!!")
self.resetFrame()
continue
```
`self.resetFrame()` probably clears the buffer. Let me check `resetFrame` (it wasn't in the `read_file` output, oh wait, I didn't see it yet because it might be in `ModbusFramer` base class or I missed it).
Wait, `ModbusFramer` is in `pymodbus/framer/base.py`. Let me check that.
Actually, looking at `socket_framer.py` again, `resetFrame` is called but not defined in `ModbusSocketFramer`. It must be in `ModbusFramer`.
If `checkFrame()` returns `False` because the frame is incomplete, the current code logs "Frame check failed, ignoring!!" and calls `resetFrame()`. This is exactly what the user reported!
The `checkFrame` method correctly returns `False` if we don't have enough data yet:
```python
# we have at least a complete message, continue
elif len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1 >= self._header["len"]:
return True
# we don't have enough of a message yet, wait
return False
```
But `frameProcessIncomingPacket` treats `False` as a failure and resets the frame, instead of just breaking the loop and waiting for more data.
It should be:
```python
if not self.checkFrame():
# we don't have enough of a message yet, wait
break
```
Let's verify where `resetFrame` is defined.
TOOL CALL · read_file
{
"filepath": "pymodbus/framer/base.py"
}Result of read_file 4,882 characters
{
"status": "ok",
"filepath": "pymodbus/framer/base.py",
"content": "\"\"\"Framer start.\"\"\"\n# pylint: disable=missing-type-doc\nfrom __future__ import annotations\n\nfrom typing import Any\n\nfrom pymodbus.factory import ClientDecoder, ServerDecoder\nfrom pymodbus.logging import Log\n\n\n# Unit ID, Function Code\nBYTE_ORDER = \">\"\nFRAME_HEADER = \"BB\"\n\n# Transaction Id, Protocol ID, Length, Unit ID, Function Code\nSOCKET_FRAME_HEADER = BYTE_ORDER + \"HHH\" + FRAME_HEADER\n\n# Function Code\nTLS_FRAME_HEADER = BYTE_ORDER + \"B\"\n\n\nclass ModbusFramer:\n \"\"\"Base Framer class.\"\"\"\n\n name = \"\"\n\n def __init__(\n self,\n decoder: ClientDecoder | ServerDecoder,\n client=None,\n ) -> None:\n \"\"\"Initialize a new instance of the framer.\n\n :param decoder: The decoder implementation to use\n \"\"\"\n self.decoder = decoder\n self.client = client\n self._header: dict[str, Any] = {\n \"lrc\": \"0000\",\n \"len\": 0,\n \"uid\": 0x00,\n \"tid\": 0,\n \"pid\": 0,\n \"crc\": b\"\\x00\\x00\",\n }\n self._buffer = b\"\"\n\n def _validate_slave_id(self, slaves: list, single: bool) -> bool:\n \"\"\"Validate if the received data is valid for the client.\n\n :param slaves: list of slave id for which the transaction is valid\n :param single: Set to true to treat this as a single context\n :return:\n \"\"\"\n if single:\n return True\n if 0 in slaves or 0xFF in slaves:\n # Handle Modbus TCP slave identifier (0x00 0r 0xFF)\n # in asynchronous requests\n return True\n return self._header[\"uid\"] in slaves\n\n def sendPacket(self, message):\n \"\"\"Send packets on the bus.\n\n With 3.5char delay between frames\n :param message: Message to be sent over the bus\n :return:\n \"\"\"\n return self.client.send(message)\n\n def recvPacket(self, size):\n \"\"\"Receive packet from the bus.\n\n With specified len\n :param size: Number of bytes to read\n :return:\n \"\"\"\n return self.client.recv(size)\n\n def resetFrame(self):\n \"\"\"Reset the entire message frame.\n\n This allows us to skip ovver errors that may be in the stream.\n It is hard to know if we are simply out of sync or if there is\n an error in the stream as we have no way to check the start or\n end of the message (python just doesn't have the resolution to\n check for millisecond delays).\n \"\"\"\n Log.debug(\n \"Resetting frame - Current Frame in buffer - {}\", self._buffer, \":hex\"\n )\n self._buffer = b\"\"\n self._header = {\n \"lrc\": \"0000\",\n \"crc\": b\"\\x00\\x00\",\n \"len\": 0,\n \"uid\": 0x00,\n \"pid\": 0,\n \"tid\": 0,\n }\n\n def populateResult(self, result):\n \"\"\"Populate the modbus result header.\n\n The serial packets do not have any header information\n that is copied.\n\n :param result: The response packet\n \"\"\"\n result.slave_id = self._header.get(\"uid\", 0)\n result.transaction_id = self._header.get(\"tid\", 0)\n result.protocol_id = self._header.get(\"pid\", 0)\n\n def processIncomingPacket(self, data, callback, slave, **kwargs):\n \"\"\"Process new packet pattern.\n\n This takes in a new request packet, adds it to the current\n packet stream, and performs framing on it. That is, checks\n for complete messages, and once found, will process all that\n exist. This handles the case when we read N + 1 or 1 // N\n messages at a time instead of 1.\n\n The processed and decoded messages are pushed to the callback\n function to process and send.\n\n :param data: The new packet data\n :param callback: The function to send results to\n :param slave: Process if slave id matches, ignore otherwise (could be a\n list of slave ids (server) or single slave id(client/server))\n :param kwargs:\n :raises ModbusIOException:\n \"\"\"\n Log.debug(\"Processing: {}\", data, \":hex\")\n self._buffer += data\n if not isinstance(slave, (list, tuple)):\n slave = [slave]\n single = kwargs.pop(\"single\", False)\n self.frameProcessIncomingPacket(single, callback, slave, **kwargs)\n\n def frameProcessIncomingPacket(\n self, _single, _callback, _slave, _tid=None, **kwargs\n ):\n \"\"\"Process new packet pattern.\"\"\"",
"start_line": 1,
"end_line": 144,
"total_lines": 144,
"is_truncated": false
}Generated tokens 820 tokens · stopped: STOP
The logic in `frameProcessIncomingPacket` is:
```python
def frameProcessIncomingPacket(self, single, callback, slave, tid=None, **kwargs):
# ...
while True:
if not self.isFrameReady():
if len(self._buffer):
# Possible error ???
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self._process(callback, tid, error=True)
break
if not self.checkFrame():
Log.debug("Frame check failed, ignoring!!")
self.resetFrame()
continue
# ...
self._process(callback, tid)
```
And `isFrameReady`:
```python
def isFrameReady(self):
return len(self._buffer) > self._hsize
```
And `checkFrame`:
```python
def checkFrame(self):
if self.isFrameReady():
(
self._header["tid"],
self._header["pid"],
self._header["len"],
self._header["uid"],
) = struct.unpack(">HHHB", self._buffer[0 : self._hsize])
# someone sent us an error? ignore it
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self.advanceFrame()
# we have at least a complete message, continue
elif len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1 >= self._header["len"]:
return True
# we don't have enough of a message yet, wait
return False
```
Wait, there's a bug here. If `isFrameReady` is True (buffer size > 7), but `checkFrame` is False (meaning we don't have enough data yet for the full frame), then `frameProcessIncomingPacket` does this:
```python
if not self.checkFrame():
Log.debug("Frame check failed, ignoring!!")
self.resetFrame()
continue
```
`self.resetFrame()` probably clears the buffer. Let me check `resetFrame` (it wasn't in the `read_file` output, oh wait, I didn't see it yet because it might be in `ModbusFramer` base class or I missed it).
Wait, `ModbusFramer` is in `pymodbus/framer/base.py`. Let me check that.
Actually, looking at `socket_framer.py` again, `resetFrame` is called but not defined in `ModbusSocketFramer`. It must be in `ModbusFramer`.
If `checkFrame()` returns `False` because the frame is incomplete, the current code logs "Frame check failed, ignoring!!" and calls `resetFrame()`. This is exactly what the user reported!
The `checkFrame` method correctly returns `False` if we don't have enough data yet:
```python
# we have at least a complete message, continue
elif len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1 >= self._header["len"]:
return True
# we don't have enough of a message yet, wait
return False
```
But `frameProcessIncomingPacket` treats `False` as a failure and resets the frame, instead of just breaking the loop and waiting for more data.
It should be:
```python
if not self.checkFrame():
# we don't have enough of a message yet, wait
break
```
Let's verify where `resetFrame` is defined.
<channel|><|tool_call>call:read_file{filepath:<|"|>pymodbus/framer/base.py<|"|>}<tool_call|><|tool_response>
Turn 5at 131 s400 tokens out11,067 prompt tokens
Yes, `resetFrame` clears `self._buffer`.
So the bug is definitely in `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` in `frameProcessIncomingPacket`.
```python
def frameProcessIncomingPacket(self, single, callback, slave, tid=None, **kwargs):
# ...
while True:
if not self.isFrameReady():
if len(self._buffer):
# Possible error ???
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self._process(callback, tid, error=True)
break
if not self.checkFrame():
Log.debug("Frame check failed, ignoring!!")
self.resetFrame()
continue
# ...
```
If `isFrameReady()` is True (we have more than 7 bytes), we then call `checkFrame()`.
`checkFrame()` unpacks the header and checks if we have enough bytes for the full message.
If we don't have enough bytes, it returns `False`.
Currently, the code then logs "Frame check failed, ignoring!!" and `resetFrame()`-s, which wipes the buffer.
It *should* instead `break` the loop and wait for more data.
Let's create a reproduction script.
The user provided a snippet, but they were connecting to a real device. I should simulate the device sending a split response.
I'll use a mock server or just a simple asyncio server that sends a response split into two TCP packets.
Wait, I can just use a test. Let's look for existing tests for `ModbusSocketFramer`.
`test/test_framers.py` seems like a good place.
TOOL CALL · read_file
{
"filepath": "test/test_framers.py"
}Result of read_file 5,294 characters
{
"status": "ok",
"filepath": "test/test_framers.py",
"content": "\"\"\"Test framers.\"\"\"\nfrom unittest import mock\n\nimport pytest\n\nfrom pymodbus import Framer\nfrom pymodbus.bit_read_message import ReadCoilsRequest\nfrom pymodbus.client.base import ModbusBaseClient\nfrom pymodbus.exceptions import ModbusIOException\nfrom pymodbus.factory import ClientDecoder\nfrom pymodbus.framer.ascii_framer import ModbusAsciiFramer\nfrom pymodbus.framer.binary_framer import ModbusBinaryFramer\nfrom pymodbus.framer.rtu_framer import ModbusRtuFramer\nfrom pymodbus.transport import CommType\nfrom pymodbus.utilities import ModbusTransactionState\n\n\nBASE_PORT = 6600\n\n\nTEST_MESSAGE = b\"\\x00\\x01\\x00\\x01\\x00\\n\\xec\\x1c\"\n\n\n@pytest.fixture(name=\"rtu_framer\")\ndef fixture_rtu_framer():\n \"\"\"RTU framer.\"\"\"\n return ModbusRtuFramer(ClientDecoder())\n\n\n@pytest.fixture(name=\"ascii_framer\")\ndef fixture_ascii_framer():\n \"\"\"Ascii framer.\"\"\"\n return ModbusAsciiFramer(ClientDecoder())\n\n\n# @pytest.fixture\n# def binary_framer():\n# \"\"\"Binary framer.\"\"\"\n# return ModbusBinaryFramer(ClientDecoder())\n\n\n@pytest.mark.parametrize(\n \"framer\",\n [\n ModbusRtuFramer,\n ModbusAsciiFramer,\n ModbusBinaryFramer,\n ],\n)\ndef test_framer_initialization(framer):\n \"\"\"Test framer initialization.\"\"\"\n decoder = ClientDecoder()\n framer = framer(decoder)\n assert framer.client is None\n assert framer._buffer == b\"\" # pylint: disable=protected-access\n assert framer.decoder == decoder\n if isinstance(framer, ModbusAsciiFramer):\n assert framer._header == { # pylint: disable=protected-access\n \"tid\": 0,\n \"pid\": 0,\n \"lrc\": \"0000\",\n \"len\": 0,\n \"uid\": 0x00,\n \"crc\": b\"\\x00\\x00\",\n }\n assert framer._hsize == 0x02 # pylint: disable=protected-access\n assert framer._start == b\":\" # pylint: disable=protected-access\n assert framer._end == b\"\\r\\n\" # pylint: disable=protected-access\n elif isinstance(framer, ModbusRtuFramer):\n assert framer._header == { # pylint: disable=protected-access\n \"tid\": 0,\n \"pid\": 0,\n \"lrc\": \"0000\",\n \"uid\": 0x00,\n \"len\": 0,\n \"crc\": b\"\\x00\\x00\",\n }\n assert framer._hsize == 0x01 # pylint: disable=protected-access\n assert framer._end == b\"\\x0d\\x0a\" # pylint: disable=protected-access\n assert framer._min_frame_size == 4 # pylint: disable=protected-access\n else:\n assert framer._header == { # pylint: disable=protected-access\n \"tid\": 0,\n \"pid\": 0,\n \"lrc\": \"0000\",\n \"crc\": b\"\\x00\\x00\",\n \"len\": 0,\n \"uid\": 0x00,\n }\n assert framer._hsize == 0x01 # pylint: disable=protected-access\n assert framer._start == b\"\\x7b\" # pylint: disable=protected-access\n assert framer._end == b\"\\x7d\" # pylint: disable=protected-access\n assert framer._repeat == [ # pylint: disable=protected-access\n b\"}\"[0],\n b\"{\"[0],\n ]\n\n\n@pytest.mark.parametrize(\"data\", [(b\"\", {}), (b\"abcd\", {\"fcode\": 98, \"slave\": 97})])\ndef test_decode_data(rtu_framer, data):\n \"\"\"Test decode data.\"\"\"\n data, expected = data\n decoded = rtu_framer.decode_data(data)\n assert decoded == expected\n\n\n@pytest.mark.parametrize(\n \"data\",\n [\n (b\"\", False),\n (b\"\\x02\\x01\\x01\\x00Q\\xcc\", True),\n (b\"\\x11\\x03\\x06\\xAE\\x41\\x56\\x52\\x43\\x40\\x49\\xAD\", True), # valid frame\n (b\"\\x11\\x03\\x06\\xAE\\x41\\x56\\x52\\x43\\x40\\x49\\xAC\", False), # invalid frame CRC\n ],\n)\ndef test_check_frame(rtu_framer, data):\n \"\"\"Test check frame.\"\"\"\n data, expected = data\n rtu_framer._buffer = data # pylint: disable=protected-access\n assert expected == rtu_framer.checkFrame()\n\n\n@pytest.mark.parametrize(\n \"data\",\n [\n (b\"\", {\"uid\": 0x00, \"len\": 0, \"crc\": b\"\\x00\\x00\"}, b\"\"),\n (b\"abcd\", {\"uid\": 0x00, \"len\": 2, \"crc\": b\"\\x00\\x00\"}, b\"cd\"),\n (\n b\"\\x11\\x03\\x06\\xAE\\x41\\x56\\x52\\x43\\x40\\x49\\xAD\\x12\\x03\", # real case, frame size is 11\n {\"uid\": 0x00, \"len\": 11, \"crc\": b\"\\x00\\x00\"},\n b\"\\x12\\x03\",\n ),\n ],\n)\ndef test_rtu_advance_framer(rtu_framer, data):\n \"\"\"Test rtu advance framer.\"\"\"\n before_buf, before_header, after_buf = data\n\n rtu_framer._buffer = before_buf # pylint: disable=protected-access\n rtu_framer._header = before_header # pylint: disable=protected-access\n rtu_framer.advanceFrame()\n assert rtu_framer._header == { # pylint: disable=protected-access\n \"uid\": 0x00,\n \"len\": 0,\n \"crc\": b\"\\x00\\x00\",\n }\n assert rtu_framer._buffer == after_buf # pylint: disable=protected-access\n\n\n@pytest.mark.parametrize(\"data\", [b\"\", b\"abcd\"])",
"start_line": 1,
"end_line": 150,
"total_lines": 361,
"is_truncated": true
}Generated tokens 400 tokens · stopped: STOP
Yes, `resetFrame` clears `self._buffer`.
So the bug is definitely in `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` in `frameProcessIncomingPacket`.
```python
def frameProcessIncomingPacket(self, single, callback, slave, tid=None, **kwargs):
# ...
while True:
if not self.isFrameReady():
if len(self._buffer):
# Possible error ???
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self._process(callback, tid, error=True)
break
if not self.checkFrame():
Log.debug("Frame check failed, ignoring!!")
self.resetFrame()
continue
# ...
```
If `isFrameReady()` is True (we have more than 7 bytes), we then call `checkFrame()`.
`checkFrame()` unpacks the header and checks if we have enough bytes for the full message.
If we don't have enough bytes, it returns `False`.
Currently, the code then logs "Frame check failed, ignoring!!" and `resetFrame()`-s, which wipes the buffer.
It *should* instead `break` the loop and wait for more data.
Let's create a reproduction script.
The user provided a snippet, but they were connecting to a real device. I should simulate the device sending a split response.
I'll use a mock server or just a simple asyncio server that sends a response split into two TCP packets.
Wait, I can just use a test. Let's look for existing tests for `ModbusSocketFramer`.
`test/test_framers.py` seems like a good place.
<channel|><|tool_call>call:read_file{filepath:<|"|>test/test_framers.py<|"|>}<tool_call|><|tool_response>
Turn 6at 137 s80 tokens out13,422 prompt tokens
I don't see `ModbusSocketFramer` tests in `test/test_framers.py` (at least not in the first 150 lines). Let me check the rest of the file.
TOOL CALL · run_command
{
"command": "grep -n \"ModbusSocketFramer\" test/test_framers.py"
}Result of run_command 127 characters
{
"status": "error",
"error_type": "CommandError",
"error_message": "",
"details": {
"stdout": "",
"stderr": "",
"exit_code": 1
}
}Generated tokens 80 tokens · stopped: STOP
I don't see `ModbusSocketFramer` tests in `test/test_framers.py` (at least not in the first 150 lines). Let me check the rest of the file.
<channel|><|tool_call>call:run_command{command:<|"|>grep -n "ModbusSocketFramer" test/test_framers.py<|"|>}<tool_call|><|tool_response>
Turn 7at 324 s3,121 tokens out13,557 prompt tokens
It seems `ModbusSocketFramer` is not tested in `test/test_framers.py`? That's strange.
Ah, maybe it's tested in `test/sub_transport/test_protocol.py` or `test/sub_client/test_client.py`?
Let's try to write a minimal reproduction script that uses `ModbusSocketFramer` directly.
```python
from pymodbus.framer.socket_framer import ModbusSocketFramer
from pymodbus.factory import ClientDecoder
from pymodbus.exceptions import ModbusIOException
def test_socket_framer_partial_packet():
decoder = ClientDecoder()
framer = ModbusSocketFramer(decoder)
# A Modbus TCP response:
# Transaction ID: 0x00 0x01 (2 bytes)
# Protocol ID: 0x00 0x00 (2 bytes)
# Length: 0x00 0x05 (2 bytes)
# Unit ID: 0x01 (1 byte)
# PDU: Function code 0x03, Byte count 0x02, Data 0x00 0x01 (4 bytes)
# Total length = 7 + 5 = 12 bytes (wait, length in MBAP is UnitID + PDU)
# MBAP: tid(2), pid(2), len(2), uid(1) -> 7 bytes.
# PDU: fcode(1), bytes(1), data(2) -> 4 bytes.
# So len = 1 + 4 = 5.
# Total packet = 7 + 4 = 11 bytes. (The MBAP length includes the UID)
# Actually, MBAP length is the number of bytes following the length field.
# So it's UID (1) + PDU (N).
# For Read Holding Registers Response:
# UID (1) + FC (1) + Byte Count (1) + Data (N)
packet = b'\x00\x01\x00\x00\x00\x05\x01\x03\x02\x00\x01'
# 0:1 1:1 2:0 3:0 4:0 5:5 6:1 7:3 8:2 9:0 10:1
# tid pid len uid fcode bytecount data[0] data[1]
# Split packet into two parts.
# First part: MBAP header + some PDU (up to 7 + 3 = 10 bytes)
part1 = packet[:10]
part2 = packet[10:] # last byte
callback = []
def cb(result):
callback.append(result)
# Initially we have an empty buffer
framer.processIncomingPacket(part1, cb, slave=[1], single=True)
# The current implementation should have called resetFrame() and cleared the buffer
# because checkFrame() would return False.
# Now send the rest
framer.processIncomingPacket(part2, cb, slave=[1], single=True)
# If the bug is present, the first part was lost, and the second part (1 byte)
# is now processed as a new packet, which will fail.
assert len(callback) == 1
```
Wait, `processIncomingPacket` in `ModbusFramer` (the base class) does:
```python
def processIncomingPacket(self, data, callback, slave, **kwargs):
# ...
self._buffer += data
# ...
self.frameProcessIncomingPacket(single, callback, slave, **kwargs)
```
So `framer.processIncomingPacket(part1, ...)` will:
1. Add `part1` to `self._buffer` (len=10).
2. Call `frameProcessIncomingPacket`.
3. `isFrameReady()` is True (10 > 7).
4. `checkFrame()`:
- tid=0, pid=0, len=5, uid=1.
- `len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1` = 10 - 7 + 1 = 4.
- `4 >= 5` is False.
- `checkFrame()` returns False.
5. `frameProcessIncomingPacket` logs "Frame check failed, ignoring!!" and calls `resetFrame()`.
6. `resetFrame()` clears `self._buffer` to `b""`.
Then `framer.processIncomingPacket(part2, ...)` will:
1. Add `part2` (1 byte) to `self._buffer` (now len=1).
2. Call `frameProcessIncomingPacket`.
3. `isFrameReady()` is False (1 <= 7).
4. Loop breaks.
5. Packet is never delivered.
Actually, the user's logs showed:
```
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 recv: 0x0 0x1 0x0 0x0 0x0 0xb 0x1 0x3 0x8 0x0 0xb5 0x12 0x2f 0x37 0x21 0x0 old_data: addr=None
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 Processing: 0x0 0x1 0x0 0x0 0x0 0xb 0x1 0x3 0x8 0x0 0xb5 0x12 0x2f 0x37 0x21 0x0
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 Frame check failed, ignoring!!
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 Resetting frame - Current Frame in buffer - 0x0 0x1 0x0 0x0 0x0 0xb 0x1 0x3 0x8 0x0 0xb5 0x12 0x2f 0x37 0x21 0x0
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 recv: 0x3 old_data: addr=None
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Processing: 0x3
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Factory Response[ReadHoldingRegistersResponse': 3]
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 ERROR logging:115 General exception: index out of range
```
In the logs, the first part was 16 bytes. The header said length 0x0b (11 bytes).
Wait, MBAP length 11 means 1 (UID) + 10 (PDU).
Total expected packet size = 7 + 10 = 17 bytes.
They received 16 bytes.
Check: `len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1` = 16 - 7 + 1 = 10.
`10 >= 11` is False. Correct.
So it called `resetFrame()`, clearing the 16 bytes.
Then it received the 17th byte (`0x3`).
And it tried to process it. Since it was only 1 byte, `isFrameReady` was False.
Wait, in the user's logs, it says:
```
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Processing: 0x3
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Factory Response[ReadHoldingRegistersResponse': 3]
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 ERROR logging:115 General exception: index out of range
```
Wait, this is interesting. The 17th byte was `0x3`.
And it seems it tried to decode it?
Let's look at `frameProcessIncomingPacket` again.
```python
def frameProcessIncomingPacket(self, single, callback, slave, tid=None, **kwargs):
while True:
if not self.isFrameReady():
if len(self._buffer):
# Possible error ???
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self._process(callback, tid, error=True)
break
```
If `isFrameReady()` is False (which it is for the 2nd packet of 1 byte), it checks `if len(self._buffer)`. Yes, 1 byte.
Then it checks `if self._header["len"] < 2`.
Wait, what is `self._header["len"]`?
After `resetFrame()`, `self._header["len"]` is 0.
So `0 < 2` is True.
Then it calls `self._process(callback, tid, error=True)`.
In `_process(callback, tid, error=True)`:
```python
def _process(self, callback, tid, error=False):
data = self._buffer if error else self.getFrame()
if (result := self.decoder.decode(data)) is None:
self.resetFrame()
raise ModbusIOException("Unable to decode request")
```
`data` becomes `self._buffer` which is `b'\x03'`.
`self.decoder.decode(b'\x03')` is called.
`ClientDecoder.decode` might be trying to parse this and failing or returning something.
The logs say `Factory Response[ReadHoldingRegistersResponse': 3]`.
So it actually decoded it as a `ReadHoldingRegistersResponse`!
And then it probably crashed when trying to access registers in it.
Anyway, the fix is to NOT `resetFrame()` and NOT `continue` when `checkFrame()` returns `False`. It should `break` and wait for more data.
Let's reproduce this with a script.
TOOL CALL · run_command
{
"command": "python3 - <<'PY'\nimport pytest\nfrom pymodbus.framer.socket_framer import ModbusSocketFramer\nfrom pymodbus.factory import ClientDecoder\nfrom pymodbus.exceptions import ModbusIOException\n\ndef test_socket_framer_partial_packet():\n decoder = ClientDecoder()\n framer = ModbusSocketFramer(decoder)\n \n # Modbus TCP response: \n # Transaction ID: 0x00 0x01\n # Protocol ID: 0x00 0x00\n # Length: 0x00 0x05 (UnitID 1 + PDU 4 bytes)\n # Unit ID: 0x01\n # PDU: FC 0x03, Byte Count 0x02, Data 0x00 0x01\n packet = b'\\x00\\x01\\x00\\x00\\x00\\x05\\x01\\x03\\x02\\x00\\x01'\n \n # Split packet: first 10 bytes, then last 1 byte.\n # Total length = 11. MBAP header (7) + PDU (4).\n # First 10 bytes means we have 3 bytes of PDU. \n # MBAP length is 5. We have 1 (UID) + 3 = 4 bytes.\n # 4 < 5, so checkFrame() should be False.\n part1 = packet[:10] \n part2 = packet[10:] \n \n callback = []\n def cb(result):\n callback.append(result)\n \n # Send first part\n framer.processIncomingPacket(part1, cb, slave=[1], single=True)\n \n # Now the buffer should still contain part1, waiting for more.\n # But with the bug, it is reset.\n \n # Send second part\n framer.processIncomingPacket(part2, cb, slave=[1], single=True)\n \n # If bug is fixed, we should have 1 result.\n # If bug is present, we likely have 0 results or a ModbusIOException.\n print(f\"Results received: {len(callback)}\")\n assert len(callback) == 1\n\nif __name__ == \"__main__\":\n try:\n test_socket_framer_partial_packet()\n print(\"Test passed!\")\n except Exception as e:\n print(f\"Test failed: {e}\")\n import traceback\n traceback.print_exc()\nPY\n"
}Result of run_command 842 characters
{
"status": "ok",
"stdout": "Test failed: Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request\n",
"stderr": "General exception: index out of range\nTraceback (most recent call last):\n File \"<stdin>\", line 46, in <module>\n File \"<stdin>\", line 37, in test_socket_framer_partial_packet\n File \"/workspace/pymodbus/framer/base.py\", line 139, in processIncomingPacket\n self.frameProcessIncomingPacket(single, callback, slave, **kwargs)\n File \"/workspace/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py\", line 136, in frameProcessIncomingPacket\n self._process(callback, tid, error=True)\n File \"/workspace/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py\", line 154, in _process\n raise ModbusIOException(\"Unable to decode request\")\npymodbus.exceptions.ModbusIOException: Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request\n",
"exit_code": 0
}Generated tokens 3,121 tokens · stopped: STOP
It seems `ModbusSocketFramer` is not tested in `test/test_framers.py`? That's strange.
Ah, maybe it's tested in `test/sub_transport/test_protocol.py` or `test/sub_client/test_client.py`?
Let's try to write a minimal reproduction script that uses `ModbusSocketFramer` directly.
```python
from pymodbus.framer.socket_framer import ModbusSocketFramer
from pymodbus.factory import ClientDecoder
from pymodbus.exceptions import ModbusIOException
def test_socket_framer_partial_packet():
decoder = ClientDecoder()
framer = ModbusSocketFramer(decoder)
# A Modbus TCP response:
# Transaction ID: 0x00 0x01 (2 bytes)
# Protocol ID: 0x00 0x00 (2 bytes)
# Length: 0x00 0x05 (2 bytes)
# Unit ID: 0x01 (1 byte)
# PDU: Function code 0x03, Byte count 0x02, Data 0x00 0x01 (4 bytes)
# Total length = 7 + 5 = 12 bytes (wait, length in MBAP is UnitID + PDU)
# MBAP: tid(2), pid(2), len(2), uid(1) -> 7 bytes.
# PDU: fcode(1), bytes(1), data(2) -> 4 bytes.
# So len = 1 + 4 = 5.
# Total packet = 7 + 4 = 11 bytes. (The MBAP length includes the UID)
# Actually, MBAP length is the number of bytes following the length field.
# So it's UID (1) + PDU (N).
# For Read Holding Registers Response:
# UID (1) + FC (1) + Byte Count (1) + Data (N)
packet = b'\x00\x01\x00\x00\x00\x05\x01\x03\x02\x00\x01'
# 0:1 1:1 2:0 3:0 4:0 5:5 6:1 7:3 8:2 9:0 10:1
# tid pid len uid fcode bytecount data[0] data[1]
# Split packet into two parts.
# First part: MBAP header + some PDU (up to 7 + 3 = 10 bytes)
part1 = packet[:10]
part2 = packet[10:] # last byte
callback = []
def cb(result):
callback.append(result)
# Initially we have an empty buffer
framer.processIncomingPacket(part1, cb, slave=[1], single=True)
# The current implementation should have called resetFrame() and cleared the buffer
# because checkFrame() would return False.
# Now send the rest
framer.processIncomingPacket(part2, cb, slave=[1], single=True)
# If the bug is present, the first part was lost, and the second part (1 byte)
# is now processed as a new packet, which will fail.
assert len(callback) == 1
```
Wait, `processIncomingPacket` in `ModbusFramer` (the base class) does:
```python
def processIncomingPacket(self, data, callback, slave, **kwargs):
# ...
self._buffer += data
# ...
self.frameProcessIncomingPacket(single, callback, slave, **kwargs)
```
So `framer.processIncomingPacket(part1, ...)` will:
1. Add `part1` to `self._buffer` (len=10).
2. Call `frameProcessIncomingPacket`.
3. `isFrameReady()` is True (10 > 7).
4. `checkFrame()`:
- tid=0, pid=0, len=5, uid=1.
- `len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1` = 10 - 7 + 1 = 4.
- `4 >= 5` is False.
- `checkFrame()` returns False.
5. `frameProcessIncomingPacket` logs "Frame check failed, ignoring!!" and calls `resetFrame()`.
6. `resetFrame()` clears `self._buffer` to `b""`.
Then `framer.processIncomingPacket(part2, ...)` will:
1. Add `part2` (1 byte) to `self._buffer` (now len=1).
2. Call `frameProcessIncomingPacket`.
3. `isFrameReady()` is False (1 <= 7).
4. Loop breaks.
5. Packet is never delivered.
Actually, the user's logs showed:
```
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 recv: 0x0 0x1 0x0 0x0 0x0 0xb 0x1 0x3 0x8 0x0 0xb5 0x12 0x2f 0x37 0x21 0x0 old_data: addr=None
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 Processing: 0x0 0x1 0x0 0x0 0x0 0xb 0x1 0x3 0x8 0x0 0xb5 0x12 0x2f 0x37 0x21 0x0
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 Frame check failed, ignoring!!
2024-01-04 11:16:16,635 DEBUG logging:103 Resetting frame - Current Frame in buffer - 0x0 0x1 0x0 0x0 0x0 0xb 0x1 0x3 0x8 0x0 0xb5 0x12 0x2f 0x37 0x21 0x0
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 recv: 0x3 old_data: addr=None
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Processing: 0x3
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Factory Response[ReadHoldingRegistersResponse': 3]
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 ERROR logging:115 General exception: index out of range
```
In the logs, the first part was 16 bytes. The header said length 0x0b (11 bytes).
Wait, MBAP length 11 means 1 (UID) + 10 (PDU).
Total expected packet size = 7 + 10 = 17 bytes.
They received 16 bytes.
Check: `len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1` = 16 - 7 + 1 = 10.
`10 >= 11` is False. Correct.
So it called `resetFrame()`, clearing the 16 bytes.
Then it received the 17th byte (`0x3`).
And it tried to process it. Since it was only 1 byte, `isFrameReady` was False.
Wait, in the user's logs, it says:
```
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Processing: 0x3
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 DEBUG logging:103 Factory Response[ReadHoldingRegistersResponse': 3]
2024-01-04 11:16:16,719 ERROR logging:115 General exception: index out of range
```
Wait, this is interesting. The 17th byte was `0x3`.
And it seems it tried to decode it?
Let's look at `frameProcessIncomingPacket` again.
```python
def frameProcessIncomingPacket(self, single, callback, slave, tid=None, **kwargs):
while True:
if not self.isFrameReady():
if len(self._buffer):
# Possible error ???
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self._process(callback, tid, error=True)
break
```
If `isFrameReady()` is False (which it is for the 2nd packet of 1 byte), it checks `if len(self._buffer)`. Yes, 1 byte.
Then it checks `if self._header["len"] < 2`.
Wait, what is `self._header["len"]`?
After `resetFrame()`, `self._header["len"]` is 0.
So `0 < 2` is True.
Then it calls `self._process(callback, tid, error=True)`.
In `_process(callback, tid, error=True)`:
```python
def _process(self, callback, tid, error=False):
data = self._buffer if error else self.getFrame()
if (result := self.decoder.decode(data)) is None:
self.resetFrame()
raise ModbusIOException("Unable to decode request")
```
`data` becomes `self._buffer` which is `b'\x03'`.
`self.decoder.decode(b'\x03')` is called.
`ClientDecoder.decode` might be trying to parse this and failing or returning something.
The logs say `Factory Response[ReadHoldingRegistersResponse': 3]`.
So it actually decoded it as a `ReadHoldingRegistersResponse`!
And then it probably crashed when trying to access registers in it.
Anyway, the fix is to NOT `resetFrame()` and NOT `continue` when `checkFrame()` returns `False`. It should `break` and wait for more data.
Let's reproduce this with a script.
<channel|><|tool_call>call:run_command{command:<|"|>python3 - <<'PY'
import pytest
from pymodbus.framer.socket_framer import ModbusSocketFramer
from pymodbus.factory import ClientDecoder
from pymodbus.exceptions import ModbusIOException
def test_socket_framer_partial_packet():
decoder = ClientDecoder()
framer = ModbusSocketFramer(decoder)
# Modbus TCP response:
# Transaction ID: 0x00 0x01
# Protocol ID: 0x00 0x00
# Length: 0x00 0x05 (UnitID 1 + PDU 4 bytes)
# Unit ID: 0x01
# PDU: FC 0x03, Byte Count 0x02, Data 0x00 0x01
packet = b'\x00\x01\x00\x00\x00\x05\x01\x03\x02\x00\x01'
# Split packet: first 10 bytes, then last 1 byte.
# Total length = 11. MBAP header (7) + PDU (4).
# First 10 bytes means we have 3 bytes of PDU.
# MBAP length is 5. We have 1 (UID) + 3 = 4 bytes.
# 4 < 5, so checkFrame() should be False.
part1 = packet[:10]
part2 = packet[10:]
callback = []
def cb(result):
callback.append(result)
# Send first part
framer.processIncomingPacket(part1, cb, slave=[1], single=True)
# Now the buffer should still contain part1, waiting for more.
# But with the bug, it is reset.
# Send second part
framer.processIncomingPacket(part2, cb, slave=[1], single=True)
# If bug is fixed, we should have 1 result.
# If bug is present, we likely have 0 results or a ModbusIOException.
print(f"Results received: {len(callback)}")
assert len(callback) == 1
if __name__ == "__main__":
try:
test_socket_framer_partial_packet()
print("Test passed!")
except Exception as e:
print(f"Test failed: {e}")
import traceback
traceback.print_exc()
PY
<|"|>}<tool_call|><|tool_response>
Turn 8at 404 s1,188 tokens out16,959 prompt tokens
The reproduction script failed as expected!
The error `Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request` happened because:
1. `part1` (10 bytes) was received.
2. `checkFrame()` returned `False` (since 10 < 11).
3. `resetFrame()` was called, clearing the buffer.
4. `part2` (1 byte) was received.
5. `isFrameReady()` was `False` (1 <= 7).
6. `len(self._buffer)` was 1.
7. `self._header["len"]` was 0 (due to `resetFrame()`), so `0 < 2` was True.
8. `_process(callback, tid, error=True)` was called with `data = self._buffer` (the 1 byte).
9. `decoder.decode(b'\x01')` returned `None` or failed, and `ModbusIOException("Unable to decode request")` was raised.
Wait, in the user's logs, `decoder.decode` returned something (`Response[ReadHoldingRegistersResponse': 3]`) then it failed with `index out of range`. In my case it raised `ModbusIOException`. Both are manifestations of the same bug.
Now I will fix it.
In `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py`, I need to change:
```python
if not self.checkFrame():
Log.debug("Frame check failed, ignoring!!")
self.resetFrame()
continue
```
to
```python
if not self.checkFrame():
break
```
Wait, I should check if `checkFrame()` can return `False` for other reasons besides "not enough data".
Looking at `checkFrame()`:
```python
def checkFrame(self):
if self.isFrameReady():
(
self._header["tid"],
self._header["pid"],
self._header["len"],
self._header["uid"],
) = struct.unpack(">HHHB", self._buffer[0 : self._hsize])
# someone sent us an error? ignore it
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self.advanceFrame()
# we have at least a complete message, continue
elif len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1 >= self._header["len"]:
return True
# we don't have enough of a message yet, wait
return False
```
It returns `False` in two cases:
1. `isFrameReady()` is `False` (buffer <= 7 bytes).
2. `self._header["len"] >= 2` but we don't have enough bytes yet.
Both are "not enough data yet" cases.
Wait, what about `if self._header["len"] < 2`?
It calls `self.advanceFrame()` and then returns `False` (because it falls through).
`advanceFrame()` does:
```python
def advanceFrame(self):
length = self._hsize + self._header["len"] - 1
self._buffer = self._buffer[length:]
self._header = {"tid": 0, "pid": 0, "len": 0, "uid": 0}
```
If `len` < 2, it advances and returns `False`.
If we just `break` in `frameProcessIncomingPacket`, will it be okay?
Yes, because on the next `processIncomingPacket` call, we'll have more data and we'll try again.
Wait, if `checkFrame` returns `False`, the current loop in `frameProcessIncomingPacket` does `continue`. If I change it to `break`, it will stop processing and wait for more data. This is correctly what we want.
One more thing: the `if not self.isFrameReady()` block:
```python
if not self.isFrameReady():
if len(self._buffer):
# Possible error ???
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self._process(callback, tid, error=True)
break
```
This block handles the case where we have some data but not enough for a header.
If `self._header["len"] < 2`, it calls `_process(..., error=True)`.
But `self._header` is only updated in `checkFrame()`, which is only called if `isFrameReady()` is True.
So if `isFrameReady()` is False, `self._header["len"]` will be whatever it was before.
If it's the first packet, it's 0.
This logic seems a bit smelly, but the main issue is the `resetFrame()` when `checkFrame()` is False.
Let's apply the fix to `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py`.
TOOL CALL · edit_file
{
"filepath": "pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py",
"new_string": " if not self.checkFrame():\n break",
"old_string": " if not self.checkFrame():\n Log.debug(\"Frame check failed, ignoring!!\")\n self.resetFrame()\n continue"
}Result of edit_file 718 characters
{
"status": "ok",
"filepath": "pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py",
"occurrences": 1,
"strategy": "exact",
"diff": "--- a/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py\n+++ b/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py\n@@ -136,9 +136,7 @@\n self._process(callback, tid, error=True)\n break\n if not self.checkFrame():\n- Log.debug(\"Frame check failed, ignoring!!\")\n- self.resetFrame()\n- continue\n+ break\n if not self._validate_slave_id(slave, single):\n header_txt = self._header[\"uid\"]\n Log.debug(\"Not a valid slave id - {}, ignoring!!\", header_txt)\n",
"is_truncated": false
}Generated tokens 1,188 tokens · stopped: STOP
The reproduction script failed as expected!
The error `Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request` happened because:
1. `part1` (10 bytes) was received.
2. `checkFrame()` returned `False` (since 10 < 11).
3. `resetFrame()` was called, clearing the buffer.
4. `part2` (1 byte) was received.
5. `isFrameReady()` was `False` (1 <= 7).
6. `len(self._buffer)` was 1.
7. `self._header["len"]` was 0 (due to `resetFrame()`), so `0 < 2` was True.
8. `_process(callback, tid, error=True)` was called with `data = self._buffer` (the 1 byte).
9. `decoder.decode(b'\x01')` returned `None` or failed, and `ModbusIOException("Unable to decode request")` was raised.
Wait, in the user's logs, `decoder.decode` returned something (`Response[ReadHoldingRegistersResponse': 3]`) then it failed with `index out of range`. In my case it raised `ModbusIOException`. Both are manifestations of the same bug.
Now I will fix it.
In `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py`, I need to change:
```python
if not self.checkFrame():
Log.debug("Frame check failed, ignoring!!")
self.resetFrame()
continue
```
to
```python
if not self.checkFrame():
break
```
Wait, I should check if `checkFrame()` can return `False` for other reasons besides "not enough data".
Looking at `checkFrame()`:
```python
def checkFrame(self):
if self.isFrameReady():
(
self._header["tid"],
self._header["pid"],
self._header["len"],
self._header["uid"],
) = struct.unpack(">HHHB", self._buffer[0 : self._hsize])
# someone sent us an error? ignore it
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self.advanceFrame()
# we have at least a complete message, continue
elif len(self._buffer) - self._hsize + 1 >= self._header["len"]:
return True
# we don't have enough of a message yet, wait
return False
```
It returns `False` in two cases:
1. `isFrameReady()` is `False` (buffer <= 7 bytes).
2. `self._header["len"] >= 2` but we don't have enough bytes yet.
Both are "not enough data yet" cases.
Wait, what about `if self._header["len"] < 2`?
It calls `self.advanceFrame()` and then returns `False` (because it falls through).
`advanceFrame()` does:
```python
def advanceFrame(self):
length = self._hsize + self._header["len"] - 1
self._buffer = self._buffer[length:]
self._header = {"tid": 0, "pid": 0, "len": 0, "uid": 0}
```
If `len` < 2, it advances and returns `False`.
If we just `break` in `frameProcessIncomingPacket`, will it be okay?
Yes, because on the next `processIncomingPacket` call, we'll have more data and we'll try again.
Wait, if `checkFrame` returns `False`, the current loop in `frameProcessIncomingPacket` does `continue`. If I change it to `break`, it will stop processing and wait for more data. This is correctly what we want.
One more thing: the `if not self.isFrameReady()` block:
```python
if not self.isFrameReady():
if len(self._buffer):
# Possible error ???
if self._header["len"] < 2:
self._process(callback, tid, error=True)
break
```
This block handles the case where we have some data but not enough for a header.
If `self._header["len"] < 2`, it calls `_process(..., error=True)`.
But `self._header` is only updated in `checkFrame()`, which is only called if `isFrameReady()` is True.
So if `isFrameReady()` is False, `self._header["len"]` will be whatever it was before.
If it's the first packet, it's 0.
This logic seems a bit smelly, but the main issue is the `resetFrame()` when `checkFrame()` is False.
Let's apply the fix to `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py`.
<channel|><|tool_call>call:edit_file{filepath:<|"|>pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py<|"|>,new_string:<|"|> if not self.checkFrame():
break<|"|>,old_string:<|"|> if not self.checkFrame():
Log.debug("Frame check failed, ignoring!!")
self.resetFrame()
continue<|"|>}<tool_call|><|tool_response>
Patch, tests and logs
Final code change Included
diff --git a/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py b/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py
index 7f55eea..206dd80 100644
--- a/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py
+++ b/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py
@@ -136,9 +136,7 @@ class ModbusSocketFramer(ModbusFramer):
self._process(callback, tid, error=True)
break
if not self.checkFrame():
- Log.debug("Frame check failed, ignoring!!")
- self.resetFrame()
- continue
+ break
if not self._validate_slave_id(slave, single):
header_txt = self._header["uid"]
Log.debug("Not a valid slave id - {}, ignoring!!", header_txt)
Test output Included
============================= test session starts ============================== created: 48/48 workers 48 workers [48 items] ...............................................F [100%] =================================== FAILURES =================================== [gw0] linux -- Python 3.10.19 /usr/local/bin/python E pymodbus.exceptions.ModbusIOException: Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request ------------------------------ Captured log call ------------------------------- ERROR pymodbus.logging:logging.py:115 Unable to decode response Modbus Error: Unknown response 0 /pymodbus/pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py:152: pymodbus.exceptions.ModbusIOException: Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request ==================================== PASSES ==================================== _________________________________ test_process _________________________________ [gw0] linux -- Python 3.10.19 /usr/local/bin/python ------------------------------ Captured log call ------------------------------- ERROR pymodbus.logging:logging.py:115 General exception: index out of range - generated xml file: /tmp/rebench-grade-196854381c5a4620bd16ab30ad6e0f4a.xml -- =========================== short test summary info ============================ PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_framer_initialization[ModbusRtuFramer] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_framer_initialization[ModbusAsciiFramer] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_framer_initialization[ModbusBinaryFramer] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_decode_data[data0] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_decode_data[data1] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_check_frame[data0] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_check_frame[data1] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_check_frame[data2] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_check_frame[data3] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_advance_framer[data0] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_advance_framer[data1] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_advance_framer[data2] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_reset_framer[] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_reset_framer[abcd] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_is_frame_ready[data0] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_is_frame_ready[data1] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_is_frame_ready[data2] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_is_frame_ready[data3] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_is_frame_ready[data4] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_is_frame_ready[data5] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_is_frame_ready[data6] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_populate_header_fail[] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_populate_header_fail[\x11] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_populate_header_fail[\x11\x03] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_populate_header_fail[\x11\x03\x06] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_populate_header_fail[\x11\x03\x06\xaeAVRC@C] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_populate_header[data0] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_populate_header[data1] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_get_frame PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_populate_result PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_incoming_packet[data0] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_incoming_packet[data1] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_incoming_packet[data2] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_incoming_packet[data3] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_incoming_packet[data4] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_incoming_packet[data5] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_incoming_packet[data6] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_incoming_packet[data7] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_incoming_packet[data8] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_rtu_incoming_packet[data9] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_build_packet PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_send_packet PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_recv_packet PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_process PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_validate__slave_id PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_decode_ascii_data[:010100010001FC\r\n] PASSED test/test_framers.py::test_decode_ascii_data[] FAILED test/test_framers.py::test_recv_split_packet - pymodbus.exceptions.Mod... ======================== 1 failed, 47 passed in 11.75s =========================
Test errors Included
Test report (JUnit) Included
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><testsuites name="pytest tests"><testsuite name="pytest" errors="0" failures="1" skipped="0" tests="48" time="11.750" timestamp="2026-11-14T03:32:31.465957+00:00" hostname="cc11e8acbd1f"><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_framer_initialization[ModbusRtuFramer]" time="0.200" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_framer_initialization[ModbusAsciiFramer]" time="0.198" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_framer_initialization[ModbusBinaryFramer]" time="0.199" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_decode_data[data0]" time="0.103" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_decode_data[data1]" time="0.397" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_check_frame[data0]" time="0.198" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_check_frame[data1]" time="0.103" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_check_frame[data2]" time="0.199" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_check_frame[data3]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_advance_framer[data0]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_advance_framer[data1]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_advance_framer[data2]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_reset_framer[]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_reset_framer[abcd]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_is_frame_ready[data0]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_is_frame_ready[data1]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_is_frame_ready[data2]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_is_frame_ready[data3]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_is_frame_ready[data4]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_is_frame_ready[data5]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_is_frame_ready[data6]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_populate_header_fail[]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_populate_header_fail[\x11]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_populate_header_fail[\x11\x03]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_populate_header_fail[\x11\x03\x06]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_populate_header_fail[\x11\x03\x06\xaeAVRC@C]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_populate_header[data0]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_populate_header[data1]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_get_frame" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_populate_result" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_incoming_packet[data0]" time="0.102" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_incoming_packet[data1]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_incoming_packet[data2]" time="0.108" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_incoming_packet[data3]" time="0.102" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_incoming_packet[data4]" time="0.102" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_incoming_packet[data5]" time="0.102" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_incoming_packet[data6]" time="0.102" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_incoming_packet[data7]" time="0.102" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_incoming_packet[data8]" time="0.102" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_rtu_incoming_packet[data9]" time="0.102" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_build_packet" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_send_packet" time="1.103" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_recv_packet" time="0.102" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_process" time="0.102" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_validate__slave_id" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_decode_ascii_data[:010100010001FC\r\n]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_decode_ascii_data[]" time="0.101" /><testcase classname="test.test_framers" name="test_recv_split_packet" time="0.102"><failure message="pymodbus.exceptions.ModbusIOException: Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request">E pymodbus.exceptions.ModbusIOException: Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request</failure></testcase></testsuite></testsuites>
Agent log Included
[ 0.0s] 📋 System Prompt: You are a principal Python software engineer resolving a repository issue in `/workspace`.
[ 0.0s] 🎯 Task Prompt: You are evaluating a software engineering task for repository pymodbus-dev/pymodbus.
[ 41.5s] 💭 (1669 chars) "The user is reporting an issue where `pymodbus` fails to handle reassembled TCP segments.
Specifically, when a Modbus re..."
[ 41.5s] 🔧 run_command grep -rn --include="*.py" "processIncomingPacket" pymodbus/framer/ | grep -v "ba
[ 41.6s] → error (exit 0):
[ 48.8s] 💭 (255 chars) "Wait, `grep -rn` returned nothing? That's unexpected. I might have messed up the grep
command or the output is empty. Le..."
[ 48.8s] 📖 read_file (pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py)
[ 48.8s] ✓ {'status': 'ok', 'filepath': 'pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py', 'content': '"""Socket framer."""\n#
pylint: disable=mis…
[ 54.9s] 💭 (103 chars) "I need to see the rest of `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` to understand `_process` and
`resetFrame`."
[ 54.9s] 📖 read_file (pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py)
[ 55.0s] ✓ {'status': 'ok', 'filepath': 'pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py', 'content': ' data = self._buffer
if error else s…
[ 106.4s] 💭 (3114 chars) "The logic in `frameProcessIncomingPacket` is:
```python
def frameProcessIncomingPacket(self, single, callback, slave..."
[ 106.4s] 📖 read_file (pymodbus/framer/base.py)
[ 106.4s] ✓ {'status': 'ok', 'filepath': 'pymodbus/framer/base.py', 'content': '"""Framer start."""\n# pylint:
disable=missing-type-…
[ 128.9s] 💭 (1505 chars) "Yes, `resetFrame` clears `self._buffer`.
So the bug is definitely in `pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py` in `frameProces..."
[ 128.9s] 📖 read_file (test/test_framers.py)
[ 129.0s] ✓ {'status': 'ok', 'filepath': 'test/test_framers.py', 'content': '"""Test framers."""\nfrom unittest
import mock\n\nimpor…
[ 135.2s] 💭 (138 chars) "I don't see `ModbusSocketFramer` tests in `test/test_framers.py` (at least not in the first
150 lines). Let me check the..."
[ 135.2s] 🔧 run_command grep -n "ModbusSocketFramer" test/test_framers.py
[ 135.3s] → error (exit 0):
[ 322.1s] 💭 (6555 chars) "It seems `ModbusSocketFramer` is not tested in `test/test_framers.py`? That's strange.
Ah, maybe it's tested in `test/su..."
[ 322.1s] 🔧 run_command (53 lines) python3 - <<'PY'
[ 322.5s] → Test failed: Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request
[ 401.3s] 💭 (3861 chars) "The reproduction script failed as expected!
The error `Modbus Error: [Input/Output] Unable to decode request` happened b..."
[ 401.3s] ✏️ edit_file (pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py)
[ 401.4s] ✓ {'status': 'ok', 'filepath': 'pymodbus/framer/socket_framer.py', 'occurrences': 1, 'strategy': 'exact',
'diff': '--- a/p…
Native result row
{
"agent_error": "Agent exceeded session timeout (7.5 min)",
"duration_seconds": 467.39,
"error": "Test failures/errors recorded in JUnit XML (failures=1, errors=0)",
"grade": {
"collected_tests": 48,
"competition_junit_ok": false,
"error": "Test failures/errors recorded in JUnit XML (failures=1, errors=0)",
"required_issues_count": 1,
"resolved": false,
"status_counts": {
"FAILED": 1,
"PASSED": 47
},
"strict_clean_patch": true,
"test_exit_code": 1
},
"instance_id": "pymodbus-dev__pymodbus-1923",
"pass_idx": 0,
"patch_chars": 712,
"phase1_seconds": 454.55,
"repo": "pymodbus-dev/pymodbus",
"request_log_path": "/kaggle-root/working/r31/rollouts_X/requests/pymodbus-dev__pymodbus-1923__p0__r7.jsonl",
"resolved": false,
"rollout_idx": 7,
"run_key": "pymodbus-dev__pymodbus-1923__p0__r7",
"strict_clean_patch": true,
"tool_calls": 8,
"total_llm_calls": 8,
"trace_path": "/kaggle-root/working/r31/rollouts_X/traces/trace_pymodbus-dev__pymodbus-1923__p0__r7.json"
}